| Name | Pos | Team | Age | Injured List |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elias Diaz | C | Col | 33 | |
| Gary Sanchez | C | Mil | 31 | |
| Kris Bryant | 1B | Col | 32 | April 17, 2024:10 Day IL- |
| LaMonte Wade Jr | 1B (OF) | SF | 30 | |
| Zack Gelof | 2B | Oak | 24 | |
| Thomas Saggese | 2B | StL | 22 | |
| Jordan Westburg | 2B (3B) | Bal | 25 | |
| Bo Bichette | SS | Tor | 26 | |
| Junior Caminero | SS | TB | 20 | |
| Masyn Winn | SS | StL | 22 | |
| Alex Bregman | 3B | Hou | 30 | |
| Coby Mayo | 3B | Bal | 22 | |
| Michael Conforto | OF | SF | 31 | |
| Jasson Dominguez | OF | NYA | 21 | February 14, 2024:60 Day IL- |
| Aaron Judge | OF | NYA | 31 | |
| Jack Suwinski | OF | Pit | 25 | |
| Kyle Tucker | OF | Hou | 27 | |
| Nelson Velazquez | OF | KC | 25 | |
| James Wood | OF | Was | 21 | |
| Logan Allen | SP | Cle | 25 | |
| Griffin Canning | SP | LAA | 27 | |
| Reid Detmers | SP | LAA | 24 | |
| Bryce Elder | SP | Atl | 24 | |
| Kyle Gibson | SP | StL | 36 | |
| Dean Kremer | SP | Bal | 28 | |
| Kenta Maeda | SP | Det | 36 | |
| Matt Manning | SP | Det | 26 | |
| Cole Ragans | SP | KC | 26 | |
| Joe Ryan | SP | Min | 27 | |
| Jordan Wicks | SP | ChN | 24 | |
| Gavin Williams | SP | Cle | 24 | March 28, 2024:15 Day IL- |
| Carlos Estevez | RP | LAA | 31 | |
| Yuki Matsui | RP | SD | 28 | |
| David Robertson | RP | Tex | 39 |