| Name | Pos | Team | Age | Injured List |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| William Contreras | C | Mil | 26 | |
| Connor Wong | C | Bos | 27 | |
| Freddie Freeman | 1B | LAD | 34 | |
| Andrew Vaughn | 1B | ChA | 26 | |
| Andrés Gimenez | 2B | Cle | 25 | |
| Bryson Stott | 2B | Phi | 26 | |
| Tyler Freeman | SS (OF) | Cle | 24 | |
| Jordan Lawlar | SS | Ari | 21 | |
| Anthony Volpe | SS | NYA | 23 | |
| Matt Chapman | 3B | SF | 31 | |
| Ke'Bryan Hayes | 3B | Pit | 27 | |
| Isaac Paredes | 3B | TB | 25 | |
| Jasson Dominguez | OF | NYA | 21 | February 14, 2024:60 Day IL- |
| Riley Greene | OF | Det | 23 | |
| Aaron Judge | OF | NYA | 32 | |
| Cedric Mullins | OF | Bal | 29 | |
| Blake Perkins | OF | Mil | 27 | |
| George Springer | OF | Tor | 34 | |
| Alex Verdugo | OF | NYA | 27 | |
| Jose Berrios | SP | Tor | 29 | |
| José Butto | SP | NYN | 26 | |
| Dylan Cease | SP | SD | 28 | |
| Aaron Civale | SP | TB | 28 | |
| Nestor Cortes Jr. | SP | NYA | 29 | |
| Jacob deGrom | SP | Tex | 35 | March 22, 2024:60 Day IL- |
| George Kirby | SP | Sea | 26 | |
| Alec Marsh | SP | KC | 25 | |
| Bryce Miller | SP | Sea | 25 | |
| Charlie Morton | SP | Atl | 40 | |
| Mitchell Parker | SP | Was | 24 | |
| Spencer Turnbull | SP | Phi | 31 | |
| Brandon Woodruff | SP | Mil | 31 | February 21, 2024:60 Day IL- |
| Carlos Estevez | RP | LAA | 31 | |
| Tanner Scott | RP | Mia | 29 |