| Rank | Score | Team | Week | Owner(s) |
| 1. | 366 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 12, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 2. | 357 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 13, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 3. | 326 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 7, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 4. | 318 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 2, 2019 | Unowned Team |
| 5. | 317 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 18, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 6. | 310 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 15, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 7. | 304 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 19, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 8. | 302 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 11, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 9. | 299 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 8, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 10. | 297 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 10, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 11. | 292 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 14, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 12. | 284 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 5, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 13. | 282 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 17, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 14. | 272 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 6, 2019 | Tom Gough / Mike Krupa |
| 15. | 256 | Horseheads Buffalos | Week 3, 2019 | Unowned Team |