| Round | Overall | Player |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 12th |
SS
Barry Larkin
|
| 2 | 13th |
2B
Roberto Alomar
|
| 3 | 36th |
1B
Mark McGwire
|
| 4 | 37th |
OF
Brady Anderson
|
| 5 | 60th |
DH
Jose Canseco
|
| 6 | 61st | 3B Bobby Bonilla |
| 7 | 84th |
P
Jimmy Key
|
| 8 | 85th |
P
Mel Rojas
|
| 9 | 108th | P Todd Worrell |
| 10 | 109th |
P
Jeff Fassero
|
| 11 | 132nd |
OF
Rusty Greer
|
| 12 | 133rd |
OF
Henry Rodriguez
|
| 13 | 156th |
P
Andy Benes
|
| 14 | 157th |
P
John Franco
|
| 15 | 180th |
OF
Eric Davis
|
| 16 | 181st |
C
Mike Macfarlane
|
| 17 | 204th |
DH
Julio Franco
|
| 18 | 205th |
1B
Will Clark
|
| 19 | 228th |
3B
Russ Davis
|
| 20 | 229th | C Charles Johnson |
| 21 | 252nd |
2B
Carlos Garcia
|
| 22 | 253rd |
P
Jaime Bluma
|
| 23 | 276th |
P
Tom Gordon
|
| 24 | 277th |
P
Bob Tewksbury
|
| 25 | 300th |
P
Rick Aguilera
|
| 26 | 301st |
OF
Brooks Kieschnick
|