| Round | Overall | Player |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 5th |
1B
Albert Pujols
|
| 2 | 20th |
3B
Adrian Beltre
|
| 3 | 29th |
SP
Felix Hernandez
|
| 4 | 44th |
2B
Ben Zobrist
|
| 5 | 53rd |
C
Yadier Molina
|
| 6 | 68th |
RP
Craig Kimbrel
|
| 7 | 77th |
OF
Josh Willingham
|
| 8 | 92nd |
SP
James Shields
|
| 9 | 101st |
DH
Victor Martinez
|
| 10 | 116th |
OF
Hunter Pence
|
| 11 | 125th |
SP
Hiroki Kuroda
|
| 12 | 140th |
OF
Alexis Rios
|
| 13 | 149th |
SS
Derek Jeter
|
| 14 | 164th |
RP
Jason Motte
|
| 15 | 173rd |
SP
Jonathon Niese
|
| 16 | 188th |
SP
Anibal Sanchez
|
| 17 | 197th |
SP
Homer Bailey
|
| 18 | 212th |
OF
Shane Victorino
|
| 19 | 221st |
3B
David Freese
|
| 20 | 236th |
SS
Alexei Ramirez
|
| 21 | 245th |
C
A.J. Pierzynski
|
| 22 | 260th |
2B
Marcos Scutaro
|
| 23 | 269th |
SP
Derek Holland
|
| 24 | 284th |
OF
Oscar Taveras
|
| 25 | 293rd |
RP
Steve Cishek
|
| 26 | 308th |
SP
Marco Estrada
|
| 27 | 317th |
DH
Adam Lind
|
| 28 | 332nd |
SP
Scott Diamond
|
| 29 | 341st |
SP
Wade Davis
|